You can’t make money on advertising; you just have to seed the clouds. What you’re after is word of mouth.”

Mitch Leigh, Musician

Pros and Cons of Cloud Seeding

advantages and disadvantages of cloud seeding and weather modification

The concept of cloud seeding has become increasingly popular over the past years. In most cases, certain chemicals like silver iodide or potassium iodide are used in cloud seeding operations. Through this sort of weather modification, the amount or even the type of precipitation that falls from clouds can be altered.

Although cloud seeding can have some advantages, there are still numerous problems related to this concept. In this article, the pros and cons of cloud seeding are discussed in detail.

Audio Lesson

Advantages of Cloud Seeding

  1. Cloud seeding can help to increase the amount of rain
  2. Especially helpful in hot and dry regions of our planet
  3. Cloud seeding can be used in a rather spontaneous manner
  4. Can be applied in a rather local fashion
  5. May help to optimize crop yields
  6. Can help to reduce water scarcity in a region
  7. Cloud seeding can help to reduce poverty
  8. Airplanes are no longer necessary for cloud seeding in many cases
  9. Cloud seeding can help to prevent extreme weather conditions
  10. Cloud seeding may also be helpful for tourism
  11. May be able to turn hail into rain
  12. Can make our land use more efficient
  13. Cloud seeding may offer additional employment opportunities
  14. May help to improve the overall GDP in a country
  15. Cloud seeding may improve the overall quality of life of many people
  16. Cloud seeding may be helpful to feed our growing world population

Cloud seeding can help to increase the amount of rain

One major advantage of cloud seeding is that it can help to increase the amount of rain that falls in a specific region. This can be quite important in various different ways. Imagine what the control over the weather and the precipitation really means. It can give us the power to control our natural forces and can greatly improve various parts of our daily life.

Hence, cloud seeding is a promising technology and if we are able to optimize this technology over time, chances are that humanity can benefit from it a lot.

Especially helpful in hot and dry regions of our planet

Cloud seeding can be especially beneficial in hot and dry regions of our planet. In those areas, water will often be a rather scarce resource and agriculture is often not possible in an efficient manner since there is simply not enough water available to grow crops in an efficient manner. Hence, in those regions, cloud seeding can be quite helpful since it can create additional rainfalls in those regions.

This will be especially important in the future since through global warming, many regions will no longer be suitable for agriculture due to water scarcity and cloud seeding may become quite important in order to solve this problem in dry areas of our planet.

Cloud seeding can be used in a rather spontaneous manner

Another upside of cloud seeding is that this technology can be used in a rather spontaneous manner. For instance, if there is no rain for a few weeks and farmers urgently need rain for their crops, farmers can decide within a few days to use cloud seeding and can book the respective service from cloud seeding companies.

In turn, farmers can provide their crops with water whenever they urgently need it and don’t have to decide way in advance whether they want to book cloud seeding services or not.

Can be applied in a rather local fashion

Cloud seeding aims to alter precipitation in certain regions. This also implies that cloud seeding can be applied in a rather local manner, meaning that this concept can be used to get rain in a specific region while there will be no rain just a few miles away, at least if this technique is applied in a proper manner.

Therefore, cloud seeding can be used in a quite targeted manner and can also be considered as a quite efficient technique.

May help to optimize crop yields

Since farmers can use cloud seeding whenever they need increasing levels of precipitation for their plants, those plants will be supplied with water in an optimal manner and can also grow much better compared to a state where those plants would be exposed to serious droughts.

In turn, chances are that also the crop yields of farmers could be increased significantly, which would lead to higher profits for farmers in the long run.

Can help to reduce water scarcity in a region

In general, cloud seeding is a great way to mitigate the problem of water scarcity in hot and dry regions all over the world. Water scarcity will be a serious environmental problem that may threaten the livelihood of hundreds of millions of people, especially in the Southern hemisphere of our planet.

Consequently, in order to protect those people from the adverse effects of droughts, cloud seeding can be an important tool to provide the local population with sufficient water so that they can still live in their home countries and do not have to migrate to foreign countries.

Cloud seeding can help to reduce poverty

Another important benefit of cloud seeding is that it can also help us to reduce global poverty, hunger and starvation. Since water scarcity is a main factor when it comes to poverty, it is crucial that we can ensure the water supply of people in those regions somehow. One way to do this is through cloud seeding since this technique can help to increase the precipitation in dry climatic zones of our planet.

In turn, farmers could produce more crops and the overall level of poverty could be lowered in the respective region. Since water scarcity will become even worse in the future, we need tools like cloud seeding to artificially alter the weather in order to reduce poverty in many regions all over the world.

Airplanes are no longer necessary for cloud seeding in many cases

While cloud seeding had been initially done through the use of airplanes, it now does no longer require the use of planes in most cases. This also implies that we could lower the negative environmental effects of cloud seeding since if fewer planes have to be used for it, also the greenhouse gas emissions related to plane use can be lowered to a certain extent.

Cloud seeding can help to prevent extreme weather conditions

Cloud seeding is not only useful to increase precipitation in certain regions, but it can also help to reduce the risks for serious weather conditions. In fact, studies have shown that cloud seeding can reduce the risk of extreme storms in a region.

Therefore, in regions where natural disasters like serious storms are quite common, cloud seeding may also help to mitigate these problems.

Cloud seeding may also be helpful for tourism

Another upside of cloud seeding is that it can also be helpful in terms of tourism. Many people want to spend their vacation in nice natural places which are covered by tropical plants and trees instead of deserts. However, many areas across the world will look like deserts in the future due to global warming and only insufficient precipitation.

Hence, in order to make plant growth possible in those regions, cloud seeding may be used. In turn, chances that tourists will choose those regions for their vacation would likely increase as well.

May be able to turn hail into rain

Hail can be a serious cause for losses in crop yields in many countries all over the world. In fact, serious hail can destroy a high fraction of plants. In order to protect local farmers from this hail and from the related losses in yields, farmers could use cloud seeding since through the use of this technology, hail can be turned into rain, which would actually even be beneficial to improve crop yields.

Can make our land use more efficient

Cloud seeding can also help us to make our land use as efficient as possible. Up to the current day, there are still many regions all over the world where farming is done in a rather inefficient manner and significant fractions of crops are lost each year due to natural disasters or other adverse factors. Hence, in order to increase the productivity of farmers, cloud seeding can also help in this regard.

Cloud seeding may offer additional employment opportunities

The technology of cloud seeding may also provide many job opportunities in the future. Since cloud seeding will be needed much more due to global warming and the related droughts, there will also be many employees need in this industry. This can be quite helpful, especially in regions where unemployment rates are quite high and people desperately search for a job.

May help to improve the overall GDP in a country

Due to higher average crop yields related to the use of cloud seeding, chances are that the overall GDP in the respective country will increase as well. In turn, a higher GDP also implies that the local population will be able to afford more things for their daily life.

Moreover, also the tax revenue of the local government would increase as well, which also implies that more money could be spent on important infrastructure projects.

Cloud seeding may improve the overall quality of life of many people

In general, since it can increase the overall GDP and crop yields, the local population will also be able to afford more food on average. In turn, people will have more energy to work hard and to further improve their overall living conditions.

Moreover, through the increase in income and wealth due to higher crop yields related to cloud seeding, more people would be able to send their kids to school and provide them with good education.

In turn, a higher fraction of children will be able to get out of poverty since education is a key driver for success in various parts of life.

Cloud seeding may be helpful to feed our growing world population

As most of us know, our world population is growing at a rapid speed and overpopulation will become a big environmental problem in the future. In order to feed all people on our planet, we will have to use our land as efficient as possible and cloud seeding can greatly help us in this regard since it can help to make desert land suitable for farming, at least in the near future when this technology will be optimized.

Disadvantages of Cloud Seeding

  1. Concept of cloud seeding is based on the use of chemicals
  2. Cloud seeding can be costly
  3. Can lead to soil pollution
  4. Can contribute to water pollution
  5. Can lower our air quality
  6. May lead to acid rain
  7. Possible dangers to human health
  8. Potential dangers for the local flora and fauna
  9. Serious altering of natural conditions through cloud seeding
  10. Humans should not play god
  11. Plenty of knowledge needed to use this concept in a proper manner
  12. May lead to a lack of precipitation in certain areas
  13. Cloud seeding may lead to local floods
  14. Hard to control the true effects of cloud seeding
  15. Cloud seeding may do more harm than good
  16. Efficiency of cloud seeding is rather questionable
  17. Long-term effects of cloud seeding are still rather unclear

Concept of cloud seeding is based on the use of chemicals

Apart from the many important benefits of cloud seeding, there are also several downsides related to this concept. For instance, one problem of cloud seeding is that this technique relies on harmful chemicals in order to work.

Quite often, large amounts of dry ice, silver iodide or potassium iodide are used for cloud seeding. However, those chemicals can be quite harmful to our environment if they are used in an excessive manner.

Cloud seeding can be costly

Cloud seeding can also be quite expensive. Especially since the technology behind cloud seeding is not mature yet, it currently costs quite a lot of money to use cloud seeding and many poor farmers around the world will never be able to afford those immense costs.

Hence, even though this technology might be quite beneficial, it may simply not affordable for many poor people across the world.

Can lead to soil pollution

Due to the use of harmful chemicals in the cloud seeding process, also our soil can become polluted to a serious extent. The chemicals that are injected into clouds will come down as rain and harmful substances will end up in the soil. In turn, in the long run, the quality of the soil will be altered in a negative manner and farming may no longer be possible if the soil quality gets too poor.

Therefore, in the long run, cloud seeding can actually even decrease crop yields due to related changes in soil quality.

Can contribute to water pollution

Another disadvantage of cloud seeding is that it can also contribute to significant water pollution. Since the harmful chemicals that are used in cloud seeding will come down with rain, rivers and lakes will also become contaminated with those substances.

Moreover, also our groundwater will suffer quite a lot since those harmful chemicals will be washed through the soil and will end up in the groundwater sooner or later.

Can lower our air quality

Cloud seeding can also be quite harmful to local air quality. Part of the chemicals that are injected into clouds will also contaminate the air and winds may spread those chemicals over quite long distances. In turn, people living in those regions may suffer from rather poor air quality and significant air pollution related to cloud seeding.

May lead to acid rain

Under certain conditions, the chemicals that are used for cloud seeding may also lead to acid rain. Even though acid rain is often belittled by the general public, it can still be a serious environmental problem and acid rain can have many serious effects on our planet. Therefore, in order to mitigate the acid rain problem, we may also want to avoid using cloud seeding in an excessive manner.

Possible dangers to human health

Another danger of cloud seeding is that it may also lead to serious health effects for the local population. The chemicals that are used for cloud seeding will end up in our water sooner or later and if this water is not filtered and processed in a sufficient manner, chances are that the local population will drink contaminated water, which in turn can lead to many serious diseases in the long run.

Potential dangers for the local flora and fauna

Cloud seeding can not only be harmful to humans, but it can also have serious negative effects on the local flora and fauna. Many animals will drink the contaminated water related to cloud seeding and the long-term effects on those species may still be unclear.

Serious altering of natural conditions through cloud seeding

In general, cloud seeding can also be considered as a rather unnatural technique. Our intuition should tell us that injecting significant amounts of chemicals into clouds and into our air could not be good in the long term and we should be aware that this could alter our natural conditions on our planet in a rather adverse manner.

Humans should not play god

Opponents of cloud seeding also often claim that humans should not play god and cloud seeding is a technique that comes pretty close to godlike behavior. In fact, changing our natural climatic conditions is a rather sensitive topic and we should take great care not to take our power too far.

Plenty of knowledge needed to use this concept in a proper manner

Cloud seeding may be rather straightforward in theory, but the proper implementation of cloud seeding techniques takes plenty of experience and also requires the employment of highly-skilled workers. In turn, this also implies further costs since seasoned employees in this field are rare and often also quite costly.

May lead to a lack of precipitation in certain areas

While it may be possible to use cloud seeding in order to increase the level of precipitation in one area, it may also lead to a lack of precipitation in other areas.

In fact, the total amount of precipitation will not be altered through cloud seeding, only the local exposure to precipitation can be altered.

Hence, while some areas may profit from cloud seeding, other areas may actually be harmed by the use of this technology.

Cloud seeding may lead to local floods

If cloud seeding is not done in a proper manner, it can even lead to local floods. In fact, it is rather difficult to determine the number of chemicals that have to be used in order to guarantee a certain outcome since precipitation depends on many different factors. Thus, in some cases, too many chemicals may be used and the resulting floods can cause serious damage.

Hard to control the true effects of cloud seeding

In general, it is pretty hard to control the effects of cloud seeding. The amount of precipitation from cloud seeding will vary due to several different factors and it will be quite hard to use cloud seeding in a proper manner due to this high level of uncertainty regarding the true outcome.

Cloud seeding may do more harm than good

In some cases, cloud seeding may actually do much more harm than good. Hence, this technique should be used with great care in order to protect the local population from serious unwanted adverse effects of cloud seeding.

Efficiency of cloud seeding is rather questionable

There are also some scientists out there who claim that the positive effects of cloud seeding will be quite limited in most cases and that cloud seeding will not have a bright future since it will simply be not efficient enough in many cases.

Long-term effects of cloud seeding are still rather unclear

Since the technology behind cloud seeding is not mature yet and this technology has not been used for a sufficiently long period of time, the long-term effects of cloud seeding for our environment may still be rather unclear and therefore, we should use this technology with great care in order to avoid any unpleasant consequences in the long run.

Top 10 Cloud Seeding Pros & Cons – Summary List

Cloud Seeding ProsCloud Seeding Cons
Cloud seeding can increase crop yieldsCloud seeding can be costly
Can help to reduce global hungerWeather modification may be risky
Cloud seeding can help to reduce povertyCan lead to air pollution
Cloud seeding can be applied locallyCloud seeding can contribute to acid rain
Especially helpful in dry regionsSoil pollution related to cloud seeding
Can help in case of water scarcityCloud seeding can lead to water pollution
Cloud seeding can help with tourismPotential health issues
Additional employment opportunitiesCan be harmful to animals and plants
Can help to increase GDP in a countryHard to apply in a helpful manner
Can improve overall quality of life of peopleLong-term effects are rather unclear

Should We Use Cloud Seeding?

From the previous discussion, we can conclude that there are many advantages and disadvantages to cloud seeding. The future will show whether cloud seeding is really a valid option to improve the living conditions of millions of people or if we should use alternative technologies instead.

Sources

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloud_seeding

https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2018/01/does-cloud-seeding-really-work-experiment-above-idaho-suggests-humans-can-turbocharge

https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/earth-and-planetary-sciences/cloud-seeding

About the author

My name is Andreas and my mission is to educate people of all ages about our environmental problems and how everyone can make a contribution to mitigate these issues.

As I went to university and got my Master’s degree in Economics, I did plenty of research in the field of Development Economics.

After finishing university, I traveled around the world. From this time on, I wanted to make a contribution to ensure a livable future for the next generations in every part of our beautiful planet.

Wanna make a contribution to save our environment? Share it!

Pin It on Pinterest